PDA

View Full Version : Fir - A cautionary tale.


mountainmeijin
03-13-2007, 11:28 PM
My work schedule is changing so it looked like this would be my last free tuesday afternoon for a while. I decided to capitalize on it and tag Fir. What an odyssey that turned out to be...

I was in a hurry to get to the trail, since this would be a relatively long hike for starting so late in the day, even with daylight savings time in effect. I got to the Biscuit Brook trailhead by around 1:20 pm and discovered two things that my haste now cause me to lack...snow pants and snow shoes.

Me, being the brilliant guy that I am, decided that there must be a well-packed trail up Fir by now and since it was a warm day, the slacks that I was wearing would suffice if I didn't slide too much. At the register box, however, I discovered that only one person had signed in for Fir since the Valentine's Day snowstorm. Ok....well I was there, I might as well go ahead with the plan anyway. The marked trail was very well packed and by 2:20 I was passing the lean-to. I noted the spot where the previous hiker up Fir had turned off and saw that there was hardly and packed snow at all. The tracks were so faint as to be nearly invisible. Well, it couldn't hurt to try right?

Yes it could. The whole route up was a postholling hell and my stubbornness compelled me onward. I was sinking in at least above my ankles with every step, and often to my knees. So much snow entered my boots as to overpower any foot warmer. When I stopped to rest I noted that my feet actually felt warmer if I took my soaked boots off them kept them on. Trudging upward my pace slowed to a crawl...literally in some steeper spots to keep from breaking through so much. My socks had frozen to my boot liners, and my feet had become so numb by the time I crossed the 3500 foot level that my boots, liners and socks would occasionally come off my feet during a severe posthole and I would hike on a distance further, not noticing that I was barefoot. :eek:

As close as I was to the top, I decided to push for the summit, but the wide, flat summit of Fir was torturous, since I was expecting to reach the top after every rise. I dropped pack to make myself lighter...not that that helped much. Finally I found myself on a level area with several small mounds surrounding on many sides, and no further distinct general rise. However, by this time I was concerned about not just frostbite but hypothermia, since I had strung my jacket through the loops of my backpack earlier in the hike, not noticing how much it was dragging in the snow. The jacket was now cold and soaking wet. :banghead:

I decided that enough was enough and concluded that since one of the little rises nearby must be the top, I was high enough and not about to torture myself bumbling around the whole summit looking for the canister. My socks had frozen stiff and were actually making it more difficult to keep my boots on. It seemed that I lost one every dozen steps or so. If the 3500 club wants to reject me as a member because of 10 missing feet of elevation on Fir Mountain, that's their privilege. I'm counting Fir as done for now. I may eventually return to make it official, just for my own satisfaction.

I got back to my car by 9:20 PM, descending quickly but trying my hardest to step back into the holes that I made on the way up. I must say that I've found that I like hiking at night...I just wish my nighttime finished were'nt always the result of some spectacular screw-up.

Bottom line: Hike with discretion...unlike me. If you find you've forgotten some crucial piece of equipment for a hike, just swallow your pride and go home. I was fortunate enough to get down intact, but if I hadn't mustered my strength, things could have gone much worse.

TFR
03-13-2007, 11:34 PM
Yikes! I'm glad you are o.k.! :eek: Are you sure you don't have frostbite?

Please don't ever do that again!

Sometimes the worst weather to hike in is when it's just above freezing. Been there done that, but not quite as severely as you did! :D

rockysummit
03-14-2007, 10:04 AM
Wow, that could have been much worse. Glad you ultimately made it out ok. I've always said that a wet day is the coldest day for me. I'll take zero dry degrees anytime.

Jay H
03-14-2007, 10:36 AM
I don't know about you but my snowshoes, hiking poles, hat, gloves, boots have lived in my car for about 2 months now. No point taking it out if you'll just throw it in again the next weekend. I will take my winter boots out to let it dry by my wood stove but other than that, I'll leave my winter gear there! Less things to remember to toss in.

Jay

daLunartik
03-14-2007, 11:55 AM
I think part of winter hiking is making some unwise decisions, and then hopefully learning from them. The thought of it being warmer to take off your boots than to leave them on is rather scary. Even more frightening is the idea that your feet were so cold that you didn't notice your boots coming off :eek: !

Very glad that you could make this report!

And like Tom said - Don't ever do that again!

I'm with you Jay - my snowshoes and poles haven't left the back of the car since early December, plus I have an extra set of hiking clothes (w/boots) that lives in the car for just this sort of occasion.

mountainmeijin
03-14-2007, 12:26 PM
Fortunately I didn't forget my headlamp or else I'd really be in trouble. For safety gear, my headlamp, crampons, facemask, GPS and compass never leave my backpack.

Additionally, I may have scratched my cornea when I fell into a thornbush. I'll be going to a doctor soon to get that looked at. I always bring dry clothes in my car...but it so happened that I brought my change of clothes, but not my hiking clothes....I'm such an idiot at times.

funkyfreddy
03-14-2007, 01:52 PM
A friend of mine and I made the same mistake on Fir a few years back in the early spring. There was no snow at the trailhead so we left our snowshoes in the car. As soon as we hit the ridgeline we started postholing in about 3 to 4' of wet snow...... we struggled and cursed at ourselves for about an hour then turned back..... a very humbling learning experience.

We came back the next day properly equipped and easily got to the canister, so all is well that went well as they say :D

Snickers
03-14-2007, 05:55 PM
So glad to hear you made it out and you are ok. If you learned something and are ok then it was a good learning experience. My snowshoes, crampons, ice axe and stabiliciers live in my car all winter long. With it being warm it makes you think you can get away without snowpants, but as you seen that can be deceiving.

As far as making the summit, if you felt you made it, then you did. It is not about the destination, but about the journey. It sounds like your journey made you grow and that is always a win. ;)

Cindy

TFR
03-14-2007, 06:46 PM
As far as making the summit, if you felt you made it, then you did. It is not about the destination, but about the journey. It sounds like your journey made you grow and that is always a win. ;) There are 2 possibilities here:

1. You were at the summit area and you did your best to find the canister. It's even possible the canister was not there, or you walked right by it on the wrong side of the tree. I think this is acceptable.

2. You know you were close, but not truly at the summit. You should go back.

It might be hard to distinguish these 2 possibilities.

In any case, you might want to go back for your own satisfaction. This is usually not a hard hike, (it was my first Catskill 3500 climb), and you can also access Big Indian fairly easily from there. I sensed some frustration in the OP, but I believe that may change with time. I think he realized he should have turned back, but like many peakbaggers I know (myself included), they stubbornly pressed on to a goal that might have been saved for another day.

Personally, I almost climbed Cliff (http://www.adkhighpeaks.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2953&highlight=cliff) twice! :eek: (I highly recommend reading that entire thread). For my first 46R round, I counted it, because I did not know better. Eventually, I realized I needed to go back. I did, and I failed again! The 3rd time was the charm, as Gandalf says! :D

As another wise man said, "The mountains will always be there...".

mountainmeijin
03-14-2007, 09:11 PM
I'll eventually go back, if I know myself. But as for now, I'm counting it as de facto finished. My last GPS elevation reading before I dropped pack placed me at about 3520 feet and I hiked a decent distance further and gained what seemed like about another 80-100 feet or so, using the trees and my topo map as a judge of height. In any case, I had reached a large flat area after a long, but very gradual upgrade with no distinct further rise save for a few small scattered bumps.

I've marked it down on my tally sheet. I do, however, have a day off the first week of April, so I will probably return then to put the cherry on top of the sundae, so to speak.

As for frustration..."Fir, I'm gonna get you for this! Messines Ridge will look like someone kicking a pebble on a dirt road when I'm through! You're gonna be a parking lot for a mini-mall!!!" Sometimes, when your feet have frozen it helps to vent. I plan to shake hands and make up with Fir soon, though.

Jay H
03-15-2007, 07:38 AM
I have hiked Fir a couple of times, it is very deceiving because you are somewhat going up, leveling off and then the mtn goes up again which may be hard to discern when in the woods and anxious to get to the canister especially with cold feet, wet jackets, etc..

If you have a GPS and a topo program, you can always transfer the summit coordinate to your GPS..I would think the coordinates would also be online somewhere, just google it..

Jay

mudhook
03-15-2007, 08:38 AM
n 42 01.651
w 074 28.147
Having been hypothermazied once in the Biscuit valley, back when cotton was king, I won't yell at you.
This time.

NumNum
03-15-2007, 08:49 AM
I don't know about you but my snowshoes, hiking poles, hat, gloves, boots have lived in my car for about 2 months now. No point taking it out if you'll just throw it in again the next weekend. I will take my winter boots out to let it dry by my wood stove but other than that, I'll leave my winter gear there! Less things to remember to toss in.

Jay

And i thought it was just me...:D

hoosier
03-15-2007, 09:26 AM
No num num num it's not just yourself.

I have to laugh at my non-hiking friends comments when they see two pair of snowshoes in the back of my jeep.

As for Fir I got the peak twice on a hot buggy muggy summer day after a techincal issue (i.e. did not follow my compass bearing). I got turned around on the way over to Big Indian and ended up following a faint herdpath to a cannister. Suprise after 45 miuntes I was back a the Fir canister.

Bill